Mini,
Yes, the "good" elder is pretty new. Only been an elder for about 2 years, baptized in the '90's maybe in his late 30's or early 40's. He looks up to the other elders, kinda like "I don't know, I'm just the new guy." This might be his first JC. He's rather smart but fooled by the innocent looking facade of the org. I believe that he honestly thinks the elders will be fair toward us. I think this experience will change him.